Fandango recently posed the question:
Do you believe that atheism is a set of religious beliefs or is a religion in any sense? If so, why? If not, why not? Or, do you have no opinion on the matter or just don’t care one way or the other?
First, for a variety of reasons, I do care. I was exposed to some “Bible Belt” Christianity at a young-ish age and I took it seriously. Later in life I realized I never did actually believe what I was told, but some mechanism, a survival mechanism of sorts, you might say, made me try hard to. But even as a third grader, I was puzzled at some of the logic.
These Christians–the family of my “best friend” back in those days (they lived across the street)–did truly believe in what they said. They believed in God. I never questioned that, but I noticed they never really produced any real evidence of the existence of God, but only a form of logic that led them to it. Stuff like, how beautiful and complex and perfect the world is, and how that never could have come about accidentally. And there was the anecdotal evidence. One example among millions: there was the man who was shaken awake as he lay soaking in the bathtub, about to slide beneath the water and probably drown, (?) and as he opened his eyes, he saw an angel walking out of the room. And their religion had its own prophet who wrote enough books about her visions and revelations to fill a four-foot bookshelf.
She wrote that Jesus had red hair.
What was I supposed to do with this information? Now to proceed in life I had to choose, I guess, to be either deluded or guilt-ridden. Or, you know, become an atheist. And this is where Fandango came in. Is atheism, or Atheism, a religion in itself?
Paula at Light Motifs said it all but it brings up Agnosticism, the solution for people who are too superstitious to come right out and say that they don’t believe in God. They say, well, I’m not an atheist! I’m an agnostic. I’m not a bad person, I just haven’t seen proof–I need more information. The jury is still out.
It’s a copout. I don’t believe in UFOs. No lightning bolts, no probes, no harm, no foul. There is no terminology, in this particular field of study, for the cautious, superstitious naysayer, but you might say, when it comes to UFOs, I am an atheist–little “a.” Not a zealot, but more like the disinterested party. I don’t care if you believe in UFOs, though I might steer clear of you if pressed.
No patience for Atheists with a capital A. For them, it is indeed a religion. I’m not saying their belief (or lack of) is wrong; I put them in with vegans who accept your Thanksgiving dinner invitation but forward a list of acceptable ingredients for their dinner.